I am about to rebuild the shrink target in my model, and I realise I have used one method for removing the margin without ever testing the others. There are at least four in common use. I would like to compare them on a single price before anyone argues about which is correct.
Take a Bundesliga match at a soft book: home 1.28, draw 5.50, away 10.50. The book sums to 105.8%.
Fair probabilities by method:
Home: multiplicative 73.8%, additive 76.2%, power 76.5%, Shin 75.6%.
Draw: 17.2%, 16.2%, 15.7%, 16.5%.
Away: 9.0%, 7.6%, 7.8%, 8.0%.
The away fair price is 11.11 by the first method and 13.19 by the second. Same book, same quoted price, a gap of more than two points of odds. All four sum to 100%. They disagree only about where the margin sits.
Which of these is the market?
Take a Bundesliga match at a soft book: home 1.28, draw 5.50, away 10.50. The book sums to 105.8%.
Fair probabilities by method:
Home: multiplicative 73.8%, additive 76.2%, power 76.5%, Shin 75.6%.
Draw: 17.2%, 16.2%, 15.7%, 16.5%.
Away: 9.0%, 7.6%, 7.8%, 8.0%.
The away fair price is 11.11 by the first method and 13.19 by the second. Same book, same quoted price, a gap of more than two points of odds. All four sum to 100%. They disagree only about where the margin sits.
Which of these is the market?