Early Week or Near Kickoff: When Does Your Edge Actually Live?

TaffyTipster

Market Sharp
Joined
Nov 2, 2022
Messages
788
Reaction score
10
Points
8
Best bet I made all season was at five past one on a Thursday.
In the van.
Sandwich in one hand.
Squad had just been named.
Lock was out.
Price hadn't caught up yet.
Worst bet I made was twenty past seven on a Saturday.
Pub.
Third pint.
Same sport, same market.
So when does the edge actually live butt?
Early week, or near kickoff?
Or is it never about the day and always about who you are at the time?
 
I work on Pinnacle Terminal (an odds tool), so bear that in mind.

We read Pinnacle 1X2 prices for 49 matches over the 31 Oct / 1 Nov weekend. About 59% of the movement came in the last 24 hours, and the final hour moved the price more than the five hours before it in 28 of the 49. Most of the margin had already come out a day early (median 6.47% at the open, 3.52% at 24 hours out), so those late moves were the market changing its mind.

Your Thursday bet fits that pattern: squad named, price still behind. By Saturday evening the line has usually absorbed the team news and limits are higher, so there tends to be less left to find. The pint matters too. A rule like no bets after the second one costs nothing.

Numbers and method, if useful: Why Do Odds Change Before Kick-Off? Data From 49 Matches
 
Let me be clear about what the question assumes. It treats timing as one property of the market. It is two. One is the price: how good your number is relative to the eventual closing price. The other is the information: what you know when you bet versus what you will know later. They move in opposite directions, and the task is to find the point where the cost of the second is smaller than the benefit of the first.
For NFL spreads I have the data. Over the last six seasons I logged the timestamp on 1,180 bets. Placed Monday through Wednesday: 640 bets, average CLV +1.8 points, ROI +5.1%. Thursday through Saturday: 310 bets, +1.0 points, +3.9%. Sunday morning: 230 bets, +0.4 points, +2.2%. The rank order is the same on both measures, which is encouraging, but the standard error on the Sunday ROI is about 6.6 points, so I report a direction.
The mechanism is simple. An opening line is set by a small number of traders and corrected by the first wave of sharp money. That correction is where most of the value sits, and by Sunday it has been taken.
The cost is news. Early bets absorb injuries. Of the 640 early bets, 71 had a starter ruled out before kickoff in a way that invalidated my reason. Those 71 returned minus 6.8%. The other 569 returned +6.6%.
Trust the process, not your gut.
 
Exchange prices are thin until the last few hours, and early thin prices are opinions. I wait until £5,000 is matched. For me the edge lives where the liquidity does.
 
For the Bundesliga the question has a hard boundary: confirmed line-ups appear about an hour before kickoff.
Of my 2,140 bets, 1,540 were placed before the line-up and 600 after. Before: ROI +5.4%. After: +3.7%.
The after group has a smaller edge, as one would expect, because the information has been released and the market has absorbed it. What I paid for the early bets was the 11% of fixtures in which the line-up contained an unexpected absence. Those returned minus 4.8% when I had already bet.
An early bet is therefore a loan against future news, and the interest is paid in unexpected absences. I now take approximately 70% of my intended stake early and decide the remaining 30% after the line-up. Genau, I do not know the optimal split. I know that a single price was too blunt.
 
Here's what nobody wants to hear: my edge is a timing edge, and the timing is wrong in a very specific way. Public percentages only mean something once the public has bet, and the public bets in the last few hours. So I have to wait. By the time the tickets are in and the line has barely moved, the sharp side has usually already taken their price. I'm buying the leftover.
Then there's the clock again. My book updates a few minutes after the sharper books. So half the time I think I'm acting in the window where the public has arrived and the line hasn't corrected, and I'm actually acting in the window where the sharps already moved and my book hasn't caught up. (Same slow clock, new chart.)
I haven't measured which half is which. I'm saying so out loud so I'll have to.
 
Back
Top
GOALLLL!
Odds