- Joined
- Jul 11, 2008
- Messages
- 1,576
- Reaction score
- 184
- Points
- 63
This guide is for players who learned card counting systems and think they can apply them to online blackjack, or anyone wondering why online casinos don't seem worried about counters the way physical casinos are.
RNG Blackjack Shuffles After Every Hand
Most online blackjack uses random number generator software, not physical cards. These RNG games shuffle the entire deck after every single hand. There's nothing to count because the deck composition resets completely before the next hand.
When a fresh deck is dealt every hand, the count is always neutral. You never get into positive or negative count territory because the shoe never depletes. The fundamental mechanism that makes card counting work - tracking which cards have been removed from play - doesn't exist.
Players sometimes don't realize this is happening. They're sitting there counting cards, tracking the running count, converting to true count, adjusting their bets. The software is laughing at them because it's resetting the deck every single hand regardless of what they're counting. All that mental effort is completely wasted.
RNG blackjack is explicitly designed this way to prevent counting. The casino knows counting works in physical shoe games. They eliminated the vulnerability by using software that never allows deck depletion. It's mathematically impossible to gain an edge through counting when the deck is fresh every hand.
Live Dealer Games Have Terrible Penetration
Live dealer blackjack uses real cards and real dealers on video stream. You might think this is countable since physical cards are being used. The problem is penetration - how deep into the shoe the dealer goes before shuffling - is deliberately terrible.
Most live dealer games use six or eight deck shoes and cut off the last 1.5 to 2 decks with a cut card. This means you're only seeing 75-80% of the shoe at best before shuffle. With this much cut off, the count rarely gets strongly positive or negative. You don't have enough information about remaining deck composition to bet with meaningful edge.
Physical casinos typically offer better penetration than this - sometimes 85-90% of the shoe. That extra penetration matters enormously for counting. The deeper into the shoe you get, the more accurately you know what's left, the stronger your edge becomes in favorable counts. Online live dealer deliberately prevents this by cutting deep and shuffling early.
Some live dealer games shuffle even more frequently than cut card would dictate. Dealer might shuffle in middle of shoe if the table has been sitting empty or if betting patterns look suspicious. Any time a shuffle happens earlier than expected, you've lost the count buildup you were working on.
Continuous Shuffling Machines Kill Counting Completely
Some live dealer tables use continuous shuffling machines where discards get fed back into the shuffler immediately. Cards are never truly depleted from play because they're being reintroduced into the shuffler continuously. This makes counting completely pointless because there's no meaningful change in deck composition to track.
You can technically still count with CSM but the edge is so small it's not worth the effort. Maybe you get 0.1% edge in favorable situations instead of the 1-2% you'd get with good penetration in a regular shoe. That's not enough to overcome variance or make counting profitable.
Physical casinos increasingly use CSMs on low-limit blackjack tables specifically to eliminate counting without actually banning it. Online casinos do the same thing. If you see CSM mentioned in the game rules, don't bother counting. The game is designed to neutralize the strategy.
You Can't Bet Spread Properly
Card counting requires bet spreading - betting minimum when count is neutral or negative, betting maximum when count is strongly positive. Online blackjack table limits make this difficult or impossible to do profitably.
Most online tables have bet ranges like £1-£50 or £5-£100. That's a 50:1 or 20:1 spread at best. You need much larger spreads to make counting profitable, especially with poor penetration. Professional counters in casinos might spread 1:15 or even 1:20 or more. Online limits cap you at spreads that don't generate enough profit to overcome the house edge in neutral counts.
Even if the spread is technically possible, making such dramatic bet changes online is a red flag. Going from £5 to £100 repeatedly based on count is obvious even to automated software. Physical casinos have to watch you carefully to spot this. Online casinos can track your entire betting history instantly and algorithmically detect counting patterns.
The other problem is minimum bets online are often too high relative to what you'd want to bet in negative counts. If minimum is £5 and you're a small bankroll player, you can't really spread effectively. In a casino you could find £1 minimum tables and spread to £15-20 in positive counts. Online, the economics of counting just don't work for most players.
Software Can Detect Counting Patterns Instantly
Physical casinos need pit bosses and surveillance to spot card counters. They're watching for bet spreads, counting errors, team play signals. It takes time and attention. Online casinos can detect these patterns instantly through software that tracks every bet and every decision you make.
The software knows what the count is on every hand. It can compare your betting patterns to expected counting strategy. If you're betting more when count is high and less when count is low, even in live dealer games, the software flags your account. No human judgment needed, no pit boss hovering over your shoulder. Just algorithms identifying correlation between count and bet size.
Once flagged, the casino can take action without you ever knowing. They might shuffle more frequently when you're betting. They might lower your table limits so your spread is capped. They might just ban you from blackjack entirely or close your account. All of this happens behind the scenes with no confrontation.
Unlike physical casinos where counters can employ camouflage plays or move between casinos, online casinos can coordinate. Many online casinos share data or are owned by the same companies. Get flagged at one site and you might find you're limited across multiple sites. There's nowhere to hide online.
Camouflage Doesn't Work Either
In physical casinos, counters use camouflage - making deliberately bad plays occasionally, betting erratically, acting drunk, anything to avoid looking like a counter. Online, camouflage is worthless because the software is tracking perfect mathematical play patterns. Making intentional errors just costs you money without preventing detection.
You also can't use the social tricks that work in casinos. Acting friendly with pit boss, tipping dealers, blending in with recreational players. Online, you're just data. The software doesn't care if you're nice. It identifies betting patterns that correlate with counting and takes action.
Multi-Hand and Side Bets Complicate Everything
Online blackjack often allows playing multiple hands simultaneously. This seems like it would help counting because you're seeing more cards per round. Actually, it makes counting harder and less profitable because you're forced to bet on all hands before any cards are dealt.
In physical casinos counting single deck or double deck, you might vary whether you play one or two hands based on count. Online, you're locked into however many hands you're playing before the count develops. You can't dynamically adjust position size based on the count in the same way.
Side bets online complicate counting because some side bets are actually countable with different counting systems. But the penetration and shuffle rules that make the main game uncountable also make side bets unprofitable to count. You'd need to track multiple counts simultaneously for tiny edges that probably don't overcome the house edge on side bets.
Some players think they can count side bets and ignore the main game. The math rarely works. Side bets have massive house edges that you need enormous bankroll to overcome even with counting. The variance is brutal and the edges are tiny. You're better off not playing side bets at all than trying to count them.
The Speed of Play Destroys Bankroll Management
Online blackjack plays much faster than physical casino blackjack. Physical casino might be 60 hands per hour. Online live dealer is 150-200 hands per hour. RNG blackjack can be 300+ hands per hour if you're clicking fast. This speed dramatically changes the bankroll requirements for counting.
Card counting requires huge bankroll relative to bet size because of variance. Even with an edge, you'll have losing stretches that can wipe out undersized bankrolls. Physical casinos playing 60 hands per hour gives you time to grind through variance. Online playing 200-300 hands per hour accelerates variance and requires even larger bankrolls to survive.
Most players don't have the bankroll to count online even if the conditions allowed it. If you're betting £10-50 spread, you probably need £10,000+ bankroll to safely handle online blackjack variance. That's way more than most online players have allocated to their casino account.
The speed also increases mistakes. Counting accurately while playing 200 hands per hour online is harder than counting 60 hands per hour in a casino. You're more likely to lose the count, more likely to make betting errors, more likely to misplay hands because you're rushing. Each error costs money and reduces whatever tiny edge you thought you had.
Even If You Could Count, The Edge Would Be Tiny
Let's say you found an online live dealer game with decent penetration and you could count without detection. The edge you'd get is probably 0.5-1% at best with proper bet spreading. That's much smaller than what experienced counters get in good physical casino games, which might be 1-2% or higher.
A 0.5% edge sounds good until you factor in variance and required bankroll. You need massive sample size to realize that edge - tens of thousands of hands. Most online players never reach that sample because they go broke during negative variance or get detected and limited before accumulating enough hands.
The opportunity cost is also terrible. If you have the skill to count cards accurately, you're better off finding good physical casino games where conditions are better and edges are larger. Grinding tiny edges online while fighting shuffle rules and detection software isn't worth the effort.
And you're still facing the risk of account closure or limits. Even if you're somehow profitable counting online, the casino can just ban you at any time. You have no recourse, no way to appeal, no alternative casino to move to because they're all watching for the same patterns. Physical casinos might back you off but you can go to different casinos. Online, you're done.
Automated Play Is Detectable and Against Terms
Some players think they can program bots to count cards and play optimally online. This is against every online casino's terms of service and will get your account banned immediately when detected. Casinos have sophisticated detection for automated play patterns.
Bots would theoretically solve the speed and accuracy problems with counting. But they're also obvious to detect because they play too perfectly with too consistent timing. Human players have variation in decision time, make occasional errors, take breaks. Bots are mechanical and identifiable.
Even if you could avoid detection temporarily, running a bot violates terms of service and the casino can confiscate any winnings and ban your account. You're risking criminal fraud charges in some jurisdictions. It's not worth it for tiny edges that probably don't even exist with online game conditions.
The Casino Has No Reason to Offer Countable Games
Physical casinos offer shoe games with decent penetration because players demand it and because monitoring for counters is manageable. Online casinos have no such pressure. They can design games however they want, and they design them to be uncountable because there's no downside to doing so.
Players don't avoid online blackjack because of poor penetration or frequent shuffles. Recreational players don't notice or care. The casino eliminates any counting risk without losing customers. It's pure upside for them to make games uncountable.
This means you'll never find a genuinely countable online blackjack game unless it's a mistake or oversight that gets corrected quickly. The casino has every incentive to prevent counting and no incentive to allow it. The games are designed from the ground up to neutralize the strategy.
Even if a game accidentally had good conditions for counting, word would spread quickly and the casino would adjust. Unlike physical casinos where table limits and rules can't change instantly, online casinos can patch games, adjust shuffle points, or remove games entirely. Any exploitable condition gets fixed fast.
Your Time Is Better Spent Elsewhere
Learning to count cards takes significant time and effort. Practicing until you're fast and accurate, learning to convert running count to true count, memorizing strategy deviations for different counts. If you're doing all this to play online blackjack, you're wasting that effort because the games aren't countable.
If you want to count cards, find good physical casino games and play there. Yes, physical casinos will eventually back you off if you're successful, but at least you have a chance of making money before that happens. Online, you never have a chance because the games are designed to be uncountable from the start.
If you're stuck playing online because you don't have access to physical casinos, don't bother trying to count. Just play optimal basic strategy and accept you're playing for entertainment with a small house edge. Treating online blackjack as beatable through counting is setting yourself up for frustration and losses.
Better yet, if you're good enough at card counting to want to apply it, use those analytical skills on something else. Poker, sports betting, literally anything where the edge isn't deliberately eliminated by game design. Online blackjack is optimized to extract money from players. No amount of counting skill changes that.
FAQ
Are there any online blackjack games that can be counted?
Not really. RNG games shuffle after every hand making counting impossible. Live dealer games have terrible penetration and frequent shuffles. Even if you found a game with decent conditions, the casino would detect counting patterns through software and limit or ban you. The game design and detection systems eliminate any practical possibility of profitable counting online.
What about live dealer games that claim to use real shoes?
They do use real physical cards, but they cut off so much of the shoe that counting isn't profitable. You're typically seeing less than 80% of cards before shuffle, which isn't enough penetration to generate meaningful edges even with perfect counting. The games look like physical casino blackjack but they're deliberately structured to be uncountable.
Can I practice counting online even if it doesn't work?
Sure, you can use online blackjack to practice counting mechanics and get faster at it. Just understand you're not getting realistic practice for actual advantage play because the game conditions are nothing like what you'll face in physical casinos where counting actually works. Better to use counting training software specifically designed for practice rather than actual online casino games.
Last edited:
