- Joined
- Jul 11, 2008
- Messages
- 1,476
- Reaction score
- 182
- Points
- 63
This guide is for bettors who want to understand when early betting gets you the best price, when waiting helps because the market moves in your favor, how to recognize when a number won't be available again, and why "waiting for better odds" often means missing the bet entirely.
Opening Lines Are Often the Sharpest
Betting lines open before public betting volume hits them. The opening number represents the bookmaker's best estimate of fair value based on their models and information. Before recreational money floods in, before news breaks, before everyone else bets - that opening line is often the cleanest number you'll see.Sharp bettors target opening lines aggressively because they know this window closes fast. Within a few hours, public betting patterns, news developments, and other sharp action will move the line away from the opening number. If you've identified edge at the opening line, betting immediately captures value before the market corrects.
The counterargument is that opening lines contain bookmaker mistakes that the market corrects over time. Sometimes the oddsmaker gets it wrong and the line moves toward fair value as smart money comes in. Waiting in these cases gets you a better number as the market self-corrects.
The question is whether you can consistently identify which opening lines are wrong and which are right. Most bettors can't. They think every line they want to bet is mispriced when really they're just guessing. If you're not certain the opening line is wrong, betting it immediately is usually correct because the edge you identified will probably disappear as others identify the same thing.
Public Money Moves Lines Predictably
In popular leagues and primetime games, public betting patterns are predictable. Recreational bettors love favorites and overs. They bet brand-name teams regardless of price. This money flows in throughout the week and pushes lines in predictable directions.If you're betting against public tendencies - underdogs, unders, unpopular teams - waiting can improve your number. The Cowboys open at -3, public money hammers them all week, the line moves to -4 or -4.5 by kickoff. If you wanted the opponent, waiting gave you an extra 1-1.5 points of value.
This strategy only works when you're on the contrarian side and the public is predictable. If you're betting the popular side (favorites, overs, marquee teams), waiting usually means watching the line move against you as public money pushes it further from value.
The risk with waiting is that sometimes sharp money comes in the opposite direction and moves the line away from where you expect it to go. You're waiting for the Cowboys to move from -3 to -4 so you can bet the opponent, but sharp money pounds the opponent and it moves to -2.5. You missed the best number by being clever instead of acting when you had edge.
Reverse Line Movement Signals
When a line moves opposite to public betting percentages, that's reverse line movement. The public is betting Team A but the line moves toward Team B. This signals sharp money disagrees with the public.Reverse line movement tells you where smart money is going. If you see it happening, betting with the reverse movement often makes sense because professional bettors have identified value that you can follow.
But reverse line movement also means you missed the best number. If you wanted Team B and the line has already moved from -3 to -2 because of sharp action, you're getting a worse number than the sharps got. Acting earlier would have given you -3 instead of -2.
This creates a dilemma. Waiting to confirm reverse line movement gives you confidence in your bet but costs you price. Betting immediately without confirmation gets you better price but less certainty that you're right.
News and Information Timing
Injury reports, lineup changes, weather forecasts, coaching decisions - information that affects game outcomes drops throughout the week. Waiting for this information before betting seems logical because you're making a more informed decision.The problem is everyone else is waiting for the same information. When news breaks, the market adjusts immediately. Star player ruled out, line moves 3 points within 30 seconds. You wanted to bet based on that information but by the time it's public, the edge is gone.
Sharp bettors position themselves ahead of news when possible. They track practice reports, monitor beat writers, follow injury timelines. They're betting before the official news drops because they've projected what's likely to happen. By the time casual bettors get the information, the line has moved and the value is gone.
For most bettors who don't have inside information or advanced research capabilities, betting early and accepting that you might have incomplete information is often better than waiting for news that moves the line against you when it breaks.
Weather as the Exception
Weather forecasts are one area where waiting often helps because forecasts improve dramatically in the final 24-48 hours. A forecast showing 20 mph winds on Monday might show 10 mph winds by Saturday. The line probably moved based on the Monday forecast and hasn't corrected for the improved conditions.If weather is a key factor in your handicapping, waiting until Friday or Saturday to bet makes sense. The forecast will be more accurate and you avoid betting on weather that doesn't materialize.
This mostly applies to wind in football or baseball. Rain and cold forecasts are less predictable and don't affect outcomes as consistently. Wind forecasts improve significantly in the final day before the event and betting on wind-related edges too early means betting on inaccurate information.
Closing Line Value as the Target
The closing line (the line right before the event starts) represents the market's sharpest estimate of fair value. It incorporates all available information, all betting action, all sharp money, everything. Beating the closing line consistently is the strongest indicator that you're a winning bettor.If you consistently get better numbers than the closing line, you're extracting value from the market. If your numbers are consistently worse than the closing line, you're giving value away even if you're winning individual bets.
This creates the timing paradox. Betting early increases your chance of beating the closing line because you're acting before the market moves toward efficiency. But betting early also means you sometimes bet on numbers that the market corrects against you because the opening line was actually wrong.
The research consistently shows that beating the closing line matters more than individual bet outcomes. A bettor who gets -2 when the closing line is -3.5 has made a profitable bet even if they lose. A bettor who gets -5 when the closing line is -3.5 has made an unprofitable bet even if they win.
When Waiting Actually Helps
Betting against predictable public money in popular games. If you want the unpopular side, waiting for public money to move the line gives you better numbers. Cowboys opponents, primetime underdogs, unders in nationally televised games - these benefit from waiting.Betting when you expect news that will move the line in your favor. If a key player is questionable and you think they'll be ruled out, waiting for that announcement gets you a better number on the opponent. Risk is they play and the line moves against you.
Markets with low initial liquidity that improves closer to game time. Some smaller sports or niche markets have thin early betting and thicker late betting. Waiting ensures better liquidity and potentially better prices.
Live betting opportunities where pre-match analysis doesn't provide edge but in-game developments create value. You're not waiting on the pre-match line, you're waiting for the event to start and betting based on how it unfolds.
Weather-dependent edges where forecast accuracy matters. Wind especially - waiting for final forecasts gets you better information.
But even in these situations, you're gambling that the line moves the direction you expect. Sometimes it doesn't and you miss the bet entirely. Waiting is a strategic choice with real risk of getting worse numbers or no number at all.
The "Good Number Will Come Back" Fallacy
A line opens at -3, you like it, you wait for it to move to -2.5, it moves to -4 instead. Your instinct is to wait for it to come back to -3. Sometimes it does but usually it doesn't.Lines move for reasons. If sharp money pushed it from -3 to -4, that's because informed bettors think -3 was too low. Waiting for it to come back to -3 means waiting for the smart money to be wrong, which is a bad bet in itself.
When you miss your number, accept that you missed it. Don't chase the line by betting at -4 when you only liked -3. Don't convince yourself that waiting for it to move back is smart when really you're just rationalizing missing your window.
The disciplined approach is to have a number in mind, bet when that number is available, and pass if it moves away. Waiting for the line to move back toward you is usually wishful thinking.
Position Sizing and Timing Strategy
Some bettors split their intended stake and bet at different times. Bet 60% of your desired amount at the opening line, bet the remaining 40% later if the line moves in your favor. If it moves against you, at least you got most of your position down at the good number.This splits the difference between acting immediately and waiting. You're not putting everything on the opening line in case it's mispriced, but you're not waiting entirely in case the line moves away. The compromise reduces both upside and downside.
The downside is you're creating more transactions and more opportunities for the book to flag you as a sharp bettor if you're consistently getting good numbers. You're also spending more time managing positions instead of acting decisively.
For larger bettors who are trying to get significant money down without moving markets, splitting stakes across time makes sense. For smaller bettors who can get their full amount down in one transaction, it's probably unnecessary complexity.
Sport-Specific Timing Patterns
American sports (NFL, NBA, MLB) have very efficient markets that move quickly. Waiting rarely helps because sharp action comes in fast and moves lines toward fair value within hours of opening. Early betting is usually optimal.Football (soccer) markets vary by league. Top leagues like Premier League have efficient markets similar to American sports. Lower divisions and smaller countries have less efficient markets where lines drift throughout the week. Waiting can help in inefficient markets.
Tennis has notoriously soft opening lines because it's difficult to price matches with limited data. The market often overreacts to recent results and corrects over time. Waiting can help but requires expertise to know when the opening line is wrong.
Individual sports (golf, racing, fighting) have lines that move more from betting volume than from information. Waiting to see how public money shapes the market can provide edges but you need to understand the specific market dynamics.
Each sport has its own timing patterns based on information flow and market efficiency. Learning your sport's specific patterns improves your timing decisions.
Event Importance and Market Efficiency
High-profile events have efficient markets that move fast. Super Bowl, World Cup matches, major championship games - lines are sharp from opening and waiting rarely helps. Too many eyes watching, too much money betting, too much analysis published.Low-profile events in smaller leagues have slower-moving markets. A Tuesday night second-division match might have an opening line that's still available Friday because nobody is betting it except you. Waiting doesn't cost you because the market isn't moving anyway.
Match the urgency of your timing to the profile of the event. Don't overthink timing on obscure matches that won't move. Act quickly on major events where every sharp bettor is competing for the same numbers.
In-Play Betting Changes the Calculation
Pre-match timing is about acting before the closing line. In-play timing is about reacting to match events before the market fully adjusts. These are different skills.In-play betting rewards fast analysis of unfolding events. The match starts, something happens, you recognize value before the odds adjust. Speed matters more than patient analysis. If you wait to see if your read is right, the odds have already moved.
Some bettors exclusively bet in-play because they find pre-match timing too difficult. They skip the entire debate about opening lines and closing lines and just react to what they see during the match.
The challenge with in-play betting is you're competing against traders watching the same match with better data feeds and faster execution. Unless you have information edges or analytical edges, you're probably giving away value to faster market participants.
Multiple Account Timing Strategy
Having accounts at multiple books lets you shop for the best number at any given time rather than timing your bet at one book. Line is -3 at Book A and -2.5 at Book B, you bet Book A immediately and don't worry about timing.This approach treats timing as less important than line shopping. Instead of waiting for the right time to bet at your one book, you bet at whichever book has the best number right now across all your accounts.
The practical limitation is maintaining accounts everywhere and managing balances. If you're betting $500 per game across 5 books, you need $2,500-5,000 spread across accounts to avoid constantly moving money. For serious bettors this makes sense. For casual bettors it's excessive overhead.
Line shopping effectively solves most timing problems. If the line is moving against you at Book A, it might still be good at Book B. Your timing flexibility increases when you're not locked into one book's line movement.
Simultaneous Betting to Lock Numbers
When you identify a strong edge, betting at multiple books simultaneously locks in the current number before market-wide movement. You're not waiting to see which book moves first, you're taking the current price everywhere.This requires quick execution and enough bankroll to fund multiple accounts. Professional bettors do this through betting syndicates that can place bets at 20-30 books within seconds. Individual bettors with 3-5 accounts can replicate it on a smaller scale.
The advantage is you're not exposed to the risk that the line moves between your first bet and your second bet. The disadvantage is you're signaling to multiple books at once that you think their current line is wrong, which accelerates your path to getting limited.
Psychology of Waiting vs Acting
Waiting feels smart. You're being patient, you're not rushing, you're waiting for the perfect number. But often waiting is just fear of committing. You've done the analysis, you know the current number has value, but you're hesitating because you want certainty that doesn't exist.Acting immediately feels impulsive but it's often correct. You identified edge, the number is currently available, you bet it before it goes away. This requires conviction in your analysis and acceptance that you might not get the absolute best number.
Most bettors err toward waiting too much rather than acting too quickly. They miss more good numbers by hesitating than they save by being patient. The market moves fast and edges disappear quickly. Hesitation costs money.
The psychological trick is recognizing when you're waiting for good reasons (expecting predictable line movement) versus waiting because you're scared to commit (hoping for certainty that won't come). One is strategic, the other is just fear.
Recording and Learning From Timing Decisions
Track not just whether your bets win but what number you got versus the closing line. If you consistently beat the closing line, your timing is working. If you consistently get worse than closing, you need to act faster.Record the line at the time you identified the bet, the line when you actually placed the bet, and the closing line. This shows whether your timing decisions are costing you or helping you.
Over time you'll see patterns. Maybe you consistently get good numbers on early weekday bets but bad numbers on weekend bets. Maybe you wait too long on favorites and act too quickly on underdogs. The data reveals your timing biases.
Most bettors don't track this because it's uncomfortable to confront how much value they're giving away through poor timing. But if you're serious about improving, measuring timing performance is essential.
Common Timing Mistakes
Waiting for better numbers on the side you're betting when public money is pushing the line against you. You want the favorite and wait for it to drop from -6 to -5.5, but public money pushes it to -7. You missed the best number by waiting for movement that was never going to happen.Betting too early on markets with improving information. Weather-dependent edges, injury-dependent situations where news is expected - betting Monday instead of Friday costs you accuracy.
Overthinking timing on small edges. If your edge is 2-3%, don't waste an hour debating whether to bet now or in two hours. The timing precision doesn't matter much. Act and move on.
Chasing lines that have moved away. You wanted -3, it's now -5, you bet -5 anyway because you feel committed to the bet. This is pure loss of discipline. If the number isn't good anymore, pass.
Not having a predetermined number in mind before checking the line. You look at the line, it says -4, you think "that seems okay." You're reacting to the line instead of having an independent valuation. This leads to poor timing because you're not actually identifying value.
Waiting on opening lines when you have clear edge. The line opens, you immediately see value, you wait anyway because you think you're supposed to wait. By the time you act, sharp money has moved it.
Betting immediately on closing lines out of panic. The game starts in 10 minutes, you haven't bet yet, you panic bet whatever number is available even though it's terrible. Better to miss the bet than bet a bad number.
FAQ
Should I always bet opening lines or wait for closing lines?Neither always. Opening lines are often sharp and should be bet immediately when you identify clear value. But sometimes opening lines are wrong and the market corrects them - waiting captures better numbers after correction. The key is recognizing which situation you're in. If you're betting contrarian to predictable public money, waiting often helps. If you're betting with sharp action or on unpopular games, acting early usually wins. Track your closing line value over 50+ bets to see if your timing strategy is working. Most bettors should default to earlier betting because they miss more value by waiting than they gain.
How long should I wait before placing a bet?
Depends on the specific situation, not a universal rule. For major leagues and popular games, lines move within hours of opening - waiting more than 24 hours usually means missing your number. For smaller leagues and obscure games, lines barely move all week - you can wait until day-of if you want. Weather-dependent bets benefit from waiting until 24-48 hours before the event when forecasts improve. News-dependent bets require acting before news breaks or immediately after. The question isn't "how long should I wait" but "what specific information am I waiting for and will getting that information be worth the risk that the line moves away."
What if the line moves against me after I bet?
Irrelevant to whether your bet was good. Judge bets by whether you got better than closing line, not by whether the line moved after your bet. Lines move for many reasons - news, public betting, sharp action, bookmaker adjustment. Sometimes you bet and the line moves against you because you were early on information that others found later. Sometimes it moves against you because you were wrong. Track closing line value over large samples to know if your timing creates value. Individual line moves after your bets are just noise unless the pattern holds across 50-100+ bets.
Last edited:
