When the Reason You Bet Disappears Mid-Game, Do You Stay In?

ParlayPrincess_88

Market Sharp
Joined
Aug 6, 2024
Messages
683
Reaction score
5
Points
8
Okay so a thing happened Sunday and I don't know what I'm supposed to DO in this situation lol. I bet the Chiefs -3.5 mostly because Kelce was going to feast on their linebackers (that was literally my reason, I typed it in the box and everything). Then he went down in the first quarter and didn't come back.
And I just... sat there? I didn't cash out, I didn't bet the other side, I didn't do anything. The Chiefs won by 2, so I lost. I don't know if I should've gotten out, or if staying was right because it was so close?? When the reason you bet goes away mid-game, do you stay in or get out? Is there a rule? 🏈
 
Let me be clear about the framework before the anecdotes arrive. Not acting is also a decision. Once the reason changes, holding the ticket is a new bet placed at the current price, and the only question that matters is whether you would place it now. The amount you originally staked is not an input. It is gone whether you hold or close.
So the test is simple. If you had no position and the current price on that side were offered to you, with the current information, would you take it? If yes, hold. If no, close it.
I looked at my own records. Over fifteen years there are 23 bets where news after I placed them invalidated the reason I had logged: a starter scratched, a lineman ruled out. I held 14 and returned minus 11.4% on those. I closed or hedged 9 and returned minus 3.7%, after paying the cost of exit. The standard error on samples this small is over 20 points, so I give you a direction and not a finding.
One caution about that comparison. I held the ones where the price still looked acceptable to me, so I chose them. Closing is also not free. An exit price carries the book's margin.
Trust the process, not your gut.
 
In football the tricky part is that the reason rarely vanishes cleanly. A red card is obvious, but more often it's your key player limping through twenty minutes at half pace, and by the time you're sure he's done the cash-out price already knows it too. So for me it's less stay or go and more whether the exit on offer is still fair, and it usually isn't. Has anyone actually been offered a decent price to get out after the thing they bet on had clearly gone?
 
As a coach, this is the question we answer before kickoff, not during. It's called the if/then. If our left tackle goes down in the first quarter, we go to the quick game. We don't discover that at 7:40 on a Friday night with the crowd yelling.
For my betting, the triggers are written ahead. A starter out for a reason that's tied to my thesis: I close. A weather forecast that turns on a bet that depended on it: I close all of them that shared it. A score swing against me with the thesis intact: I do nothing.
That last one is the one I'm worst at. I think there's a middle ground, and it's refusing to exit on every flicker. A good play-caller gets surprised too, Princess. The difference is he's already got the next call ready. You didn't have one, and Kelce was a thing you could have written down.
 
Here's what nobody wants to hear: my reasons can't disappear in-game, because they were never about the game. They're about the line. "Public 80% on A, line flat, fade." That's a thesis about a price, and the price stops existing at kickoff. After that I'm just a guy holding a ticket on a game I never analyzed. (My whole edge expires at the whistle and I've been saying "I'll hold" like it's a position.)
So the honest answer for me is that most of my in-game bets are bets with a dead reason from the first minute. RIP public money, but also RIP the idea that I know what I'm doing at minute 40.
 
Back
Top
GOALLLL!
Odds